City of Light, City of Dark
Avi
- Reading
- Read a few pages together first, explaining how panels and captions connect. Pause when the Power, the treaty or Sarah’s history becomes significant, then discuss whose account can be trusted.
- Themes
- Shared power and civic responsibility: The Kurbs lend the island to humans under an agreement requiring the Power to be found and returned through a ritual cycle. The arrangement invites discussion of reciprocal obligations and who has authority over a shared home, though its moral judgement is not fully established.
- Secrets, truth and family identity: Sarah has been told that her mother died, while secrets about her history are entwined with the token and its protection. The book’s stance on this remains unclear.
- Graphic storytelling and reading perspective: The book combines illustrated narrative, comic-book panels, captions and dialogue, with some dialogue presented in both Spanish and English. Meaning is distributed across words and images, so readers may notice how panel sequence, framing and captions shape the adventure.
- Worth knowing
- Some readers may want preparation for peril involving a threatened freezing city, an attempted theft, a character’s blindness and suspenseful pursuit. Family separation and false information about a parent also matter.