Nine Liars
Maureen Johnson
- Reading
- If the darker material may be difficult, discuss the murder and drowning content before reading. The past-and-present structure makes it useful to pause after revelations and compare changing interpretations without spoilers.
- Themes
- Truth, secrecy and investigation: Stevie investigates whether the accepted explanation for the 1995 deaths was false, while one witness has held onto an unexplained account. The story treats careful examination of evidence as central and presents crime sensationalism negatively.
- Friendship and accountability: Stevie’s group is contrasted with the earlier group of nine, and friends are described as holding one another accountable in supportive ways. Friendship is presented as emotionally important, with honesty and mutual support carrying weight.
- Romance and uncertainty: Stevie is separated from David while thinking about love, college and life; the relationship creates uncertainty during the investigation. Romance appears as part of Stevie’s emotional pressure, but the book’s overall judgement on the relationship is not established.
- Worth knowing
- Pay particular attention to the murder investigation, including axe-related deaths, drowned women, drugging and a hinted-at sexual assault. Heavy drinking, smoking, references to weed, sexual discussion, panic and occasional strong language also occur.