SuitabookFairness and unequal fortunes
The fisherman challenges God’s claim to treat everyone alike by pointing to people whose lives are charmed and others who experience hardship.
Loading your next page
Book details
These links show the original reading lists. Inclusion is not a guarantee of suitability for your child.
Sally Nicholls - Author
This is a dark, visually distinctive folktale about a poor fisherman, Death’s unusual fairness, medicine, deception and consequences. Its accessible story shape is paired with a bleak ending that may invite thoughtful discussion.
Book Brief
Sign in to see how this book fits your child and family preferences.
Sign in for personalised guidanceThis is a dark, visually distinctive folktale about a poor fisherman, Death’s unusual fairness, medicine, deception and consequences. Its accessible story shape is paired with a bleak ending that may invite thoughtful discussion.
The fisherman challenges God’s claim to treat everyone alike by pointing to people whose lives are charmed and others who experience hardship.
Death becomes the son’s godfather and gives the fisherman a way to judge whether patients can be cured, based on where Death stands beside the bed.
Death’s information enables the fisherman to become a rich doctor, until he foolishly decides to trick Death himself.
The book includes death, illness, patients who cannot be saved, an attempt to trick Death, and an explicitly bleak ending. Consider whether this treatment suits the reader’s response to mortality and dark folktales.
This is a grounded book brief while Suitabook strengthens the analysis: another book-specific source is still needed; some draft conclusions still depend on unresolved evidence.
Anything not established here remains open; it is not being treated as absent or safe.